For young people, the job search has never been so miserable | 对年轻人来说,求职从未如此痛苦 - FT中文网
登录×
电子邮件/用户名
密码
记住我
请输入邮箱和密码进行绑定操作:
请输入手机号码,通过短信验证(目前仅支持中国大陆地区的手机号):
请您阅读我们的用户注册协议隐私权保护政策,点击下方按钮即视为您接受。
FT英语电台

For young people, the job search has never been so miserable
对年轻人来说,求职从未如此痛苦

Automated application processes are dehumanising and unhelpful
00:00

undefined

The writer is the author of ‘Uncharted: How to Navigate the Future’

I’m currently employing a young man, a recent graduate with a degree in cyber security. But he’s not keeping my network safe from hackers. He’s splitting logs, because the hours he is spending alone online, searching for his first job, are leaving him isolated and depressed. His mother was almost in tears worrying about him. My view was that one small help might be some work that gets him out of the house and gives him a bit of fresh air, exercise and cash. 

It’s a poor solution to a desperate problem. He is one of tens of thousands of young people, often derided by older generations as snowflakes or slackers. But he is none of these things. He turns up on time and does excellent work. If I were still running software companies, I’d give him a try. At least an interview. Except that that isn’t how the job market works these days. Instead, the world’s bedrooms are full of lonely young people wading through websites that promise their efficient algorithmic filtering will take them straight to the dream job. In fact they do no such thing. 

Just try it. On some of the most popular job hunt websites, I submitted search terms including the words “entry level” or “junior”, and received pages and pages of jobs, most requiring at least three, even five, years of experience. It’s a terrible business model that values high traffic and time spent on site over accuracy. But of course, the applicants aren’t the customers — advertisers are. Who cares if kids who just want their first real job burn themselves out wading through pages and pages of irrelevant ads that essentially convey a simple message: you are worthless? 

If by some fluke, job searchers unearth a relevant lead, they devote countless hours to crafting a tailor-made personal statement. These applications are rarely acknowledged, and it’s unclear if anybody reads them. Instead they are scanned and mostly rejected, usually without even an automated “thanks but no thanks”. A 2021 Harvard Business School study showed that 90 per cent of employers use automated tracking software to sift through applications, even though most acknowledge that these systems vet out qualified candidates because they don’t precisely match the criteria in the job description. The rarities that get through to the next of an unknown number of rounds, often then face tests or interviews with a bot that provides no feedback.

Job seekers learn nothing from this process, only that the world doesn’t care about them. After months of searching, they feel humiliated and utterly alienated from the world of work, before they’ve even started. It is the most dehumanising process I have ever encountered. And I once worked in a call centre.

While ministers debate reducing benefits to boost incentives, they might consider how profoundly disincentivising the system for acquiring jobs is. It is a recipe for disaffection and rage. When young people see that society takes no stake in them, it’s a small step for them to reject any stake in society. A few candidates will know people who know people, but many parents don’t know how to help their children, so profoundly has the world of work changed since their first jobs. Watching this automated misery, they feel humiliated too.

Employers may imagine the system is efficient. In fact, it is a wasted opportunity. Every time someone applies for a job, there is a chance to build that company’s reputation. Those young people (and their parents) are also consumers. So this is a moment to polish a brand, not tarnish it. Kids will remember who helped and who treated them as disposable. No amount of advertising will persuade them that the companies that never replied will ever care, about people or the planet or customers.

The whole dismal system sends a weak signal for an already uncertain future. Earlier this year, research from Imperial College London found that in the two years between July 2021 and July 2023, “online freelancers in professions that are more vulnerable to automation saw an overall 21 per cent fall in weekly demand for their skills”. Lacking clout or a union, these workers are largely invisible.

Those who unthinkingly embrace technology in recruitment are wilfully blind to its consequences. Across the board we have generations of eager, able young people struggling to pay the bills and make their contribution. We should be thinking now about how to preserve social cohesion, if only for the simple reason that, without it, no business will flourish.

版权声明:本文版权归FT中文网所有,未经允许任何单位或个人不得转载,复制或以任何其他方式使用本文全部或部分,侵权必究。

欧洲病夫?德国企业老板针对高病假率发出警告

一项研究称,如果不是因为病假率高于平均水平,德国经济去年将增长0.5%,而非收缩0.3%。

依视路陆逊梯卡估值达千亿欧元,押注眼镜将取代智能手机

该眼镜巨头的首席执行官米莱里表示,与Meta公司合作开发的可穿戴技术将促进增长。

朝鲜向俄派兵后,韩国考虑直接援乌武器

韩国认为,朝鲜向俄派兵和可能的俄朝技术转让对韩国的安全构成直接威胁。

再次陷入危机的大众汽车能走上改革之路吗?

欧洲最大的汽车制造商正与工人和政界人士交战,试图渡过痛苦的电动汽车转型期。

哈里斯的另一个大选对手:通货膨胀

美国选民对高昂生活成本的不满可能决定下周谁将赢得白宫。

Lex专栏:Meta和微软通过季度理智检查

科技巨头今天吹捧真正的胜利,以证明明天的巨额投资是合理的。投资者对此是支持的,但程度有限。
设置字号×
最小
较小
默认
较大
最大
分享×